Benjamin Lynch
Honors History 10
Mrs. Gallagher
A Block
History DBQ
Charles Dickens, a famous author in Great Britain and the United States, saw the terrible living conditions that many young children had to live through while working in the mills in England. The children had to work non-stop under the supervision of very abrasive overlookers. Seeing this, Dickens travelled to the United States in hopes to find a new system of work that could be implemented into the English system to relieve the children of their misery in the mills. During the February of 1842, Dickens visited Lowell as he had heard that there were ideal working conditions for the young children in the mills and factories. Compared to the English system, he loved what he saw as there were children that seemed content with what they were doing and not one face showed an expression of misery or freight. Lowell made a great impression on Dickens, and he knew immediately that there was a more efficient way of working in the factories
While at Lowell, Dickens visited multiple factories. Some of the factories included woolen, carpet, and cotton factories. He analyzed them in a very similar fashion compared the way he analyzed factories in England. As soon as he arrived, he knew he saw what he liked. “These girls we all well dressed. They had serviceable bonnets, good warm cloaks, and shawls” [Doc. A.] Compared to the english system, where the girls had poorly woven clothing and little to know wearable protection, the American system had a clear advantage. “They were healthy in appearance, many of them remarkably so, and had the manners of young women” [Doc A.] The young girls showed no signs of misery or despair. In England, many of the girls seemed very rude and had a lack of manners, mainly due to the poor conditions they were living in. Without sufficient living conditions, the young girls in england had little to no motivation to act properly in the factory. The rooms in which the young american girls were working in were in much better shape compared to those in England. There was circulating fresh air, natural lights, cleanliness, and overall comfort. All of the faces that Dickens saw were very happy with what they were doing, and felt very safe and cared for in the environment they were working in.
Mary Paul, one of the many workers in Lowell, wrote several letters going back and forth with her father about her content in the factories. She was extremely satisfied with her living quarters and pay, and guaranteed her father at least another year there if not more. “We found a place in a spinning room and the next morning I went to work. I like very well have 50 cts first payment increasing every payment as I get along in work have a first rate overseer and a very good boarding place.” [Doc C] However, the next letter to her father expressed some concerns and dangers that she had witnessed in the factories. Many deaths and fatal accidents had occurred but did not change her perspective on how she saw lowell as a whole. “One girl fell down and broke her neck... the same day a man was killed by the cars… another was nearly killed by falling down and having a bale of cotton fall on him.” [Doc C.] In her final letter to her father, she confessed that she had been out of work for four days and insisted that her health was in good shape. In reality, she was not well at all. In 1849, she travelled back to Vermont where she worked as seamstress. Eventually, she returned to Lowell to commit to marriage. Despite some inevitable dangers in the Lowell factories, a life as a worker in America still tops a life as a worker in Great Britain.
Hannah Goode was a young girl working in the factories of England. At the age of sixteen, she was sent to the factories unwillingly by her parents in order for her to make a living. In her testimonial, she expressed nothing but discomfort and showed that she was far from content with her workplace. “It is about half past five by our clock at home when we go in...the youngest child is about seven...we never stop to take our meals, except at dinner. It has gone on this six years and more…” [Doc. D] In her letter, she also showed her freight of the overlooker in her room. “William Crookes is overlooker in our room; he is cross-tempered sometimes. He does not beat me; he beats the little children if they do not do their work right… I have sometimes seen the little children drop asleep or so, but not lately. If they are catched asleep, they get the strap.”[Doc. D] The quote shows that despite the efforts the young children put into their work, the overlooker does not tolerate exhaustion and sleep. In these working conditions, no child was satisfied and nearly all were living in misery and pain.
The days between a worker in Lowell and a worker in Great Britain varied greatly. Both started and ended at the same time, yet the American schedule was hundreds of times more efficient than the British schedule. For example, the American workers had an hour to eat their meals away from the machines and at least two hours at the end of the day to have time for themselves. For those in Great Britain, they worked non stop from 4 am in the morning, to 11pm at night. “One such girl sets these bobbins all in motion by turning a wheel at the end of the beam, a wire then catches up a flake of Wool, spins it, and gather it upon each bobbin...This is done every minute without intermission.” [Doc B.] This shows just how sharp and consistent a worker must be in England in order to keep up with the intensity of production. The British system was simply so far behind the American system that it seemed impossible to recover.
In conclusion, Dickens observed that the Americans had an exponentially greater system of work compared to England. In his writings, he took down a myriad of notes in order to show exactly how poor the English system was. Dickens was surprised to see how efficient and content the American workers were at the factories and knew that the system must be implemented immediately into Great Britain in order for the children to be happy with the work they were provided with.